What Separates Generous Families From Effective Ones In Philanthropy

Share:

Most wealthy families are generous. Far fewer are effective.

I’ve spent more than 25 years advising families, family offices and foundations on their family philanthropy, and I see this gap constantly. A family gives millions of dollars a year. They care deeply. They want their giving to matter. And yet when they step back, they can’t say what all that generosity has changed.

Recently, Colten Ratz asked me a question on the Factory Feature podcast that I haven’t stopped thinking about: What separates families that are generous with their wealth from those that are genuinely effective in creating lasting philanthropic impact?

The question has never mattered more. In what’s become known as the Great Wealth Transfer, Cerulli Associates projects that $124 trillion will change hands in the U.S. through 2048, with $18 trillion of it going to charity. Much of that charitable giving will be decided by families who are new to these decisions, whether they’re inheriting wealth, selling a business, or stepping into leadership of a family foundation. Good intentions aren’t enough to carry that much responsibility.

Why more wealth makes giving harder

You might assume philanthropy gets easier as wealth grows. In my experience, the opposite is true.

When you’re writing checks to your alma mater and a few local nonprofits, the decisions are simple. When you suddenly have $100 million to deploy, you realize how much good is possible, and the questions multiply. What do we actually care about? How do we want to make a difference? Who should we partner with? Should our children be involved?

Many families also feel a quiet fear. Larger gifts draw attention. They wonder what people will think of the causes they choose, or whether a decision will come back to haunt them. So they default to what feels safe: smaller gifts, familiar organizations, and decisions made one request at a time.

That’s generosity. Effective philanthropy asks more of us. The families who make the leap share three habits.

Habit 1: Treat family philanthropy like the business that built the wealth

The most effective families bring the same rigor to their giving that they brought to building their company. They set goals. They make decisions with a clear strategy in mind. They invest in good advice.

That rigor starts with asking questions in the right order. Families and their advisors often begin with “how” questions. How should we structure our giving – from a private foundation or a donor-advised fund? How much should we give this year? How do we involve the kids? These are good questions asked too soon.

Instead, start with why and what. Why is philanthropy important to your family? What change do we want to see, and where? What type of philanthropic family do we want to become? Once you can answer those, the right structure, budget, and grantees become much easier to choose. That’s the heart of good philanthropic planning.

Habit 2: Give from abundance

In my book Delusional Altruism, the first chapter is called “You Save Money on All the Wrong Things.” It describes a scarcity mindset I see even among the wealthiest donors.

It sounds like this: we’ll fund the tutoring program, but our grant can’t pay the salaries of the tutors. Or we only support nonprofits that spend almost nothing on overhead. It feels prudent. In practice, it starves the organizations doing the work. No business owner would expect a company to thrive without investing in staff, technology, R&D, and leadership. Nonprofits are no different.

The same mindset turns inward. I advised a family foundation whose board refused to add staff because trustees wanted to do the work themselves. Then many trustees didn’t show up, and the overstretched staff spent their days chasing trustees to make quorum in meetings instead of advancing the mission.

Effective families fund nonprofits like they want them to win. They also invest in themselves as philanthropists: learning about the issues they care about, getting good advice, and investing in their own capacity.

Habit 3: Design your giving for generations not yet born

If you hope your children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren will carry your philanthropy forward, plan for that today. The world they live in will be very different from ours. They’ll need enough context to honor your intent and enough freedom to adapt.

That means documenting why you give and what you value, through written statements, recorded conversations or family histories. It also means setting up governance that can grow with the family. One foundation I advise had a practice of encouraging any family member over 25 years old to join the board. And board members have no term limits. That worked when it was founded decades ago. Today roughly 300 family members are eligible to join the board, and the number keeps growing. Their governance model is unsustainable.

What got them here won’t get them there. So the family is rethinking its governance, including how long trustees serve and how relatives can contribute in meaningful ways without a board seat, through volunteering on committees, participating in a family council, or next-generation grantmaking. Making those changes now spares future generations from inheriting a structure they can’t manage.

Where to start: A family giving plan

The most effective philanthropists I know have one thing in common: they have a plan. A family giving plan spells out why you give, what you support, how you decide, who participates and how you put it into action.

It also gives you a simple filter for every new request. Before any major charitable commitment, ask: does this advance our giving plan, or take us off course? That one question keeps families from chasing shiny objects, like the grant made after an inspiring conversation with a stranger on a plane.

Generosity is the starting point. Lasting impact takes a plan. The families who build one now, before the next liquidity event or leadership transition, will be the ones whose philanthropy outlasts them.

Download the Article Now!

Just provide us with your name and email and receive this article.