This article was originally published on Forbes on July 10, 2026. Read the original on Forbes.
A family sells the business, settles the estate, or simply decides it’s time, and someone asks, “Should we start a foundation?” It sounds altruistic. But it’s the wrong question.
The questions that actually matter start with why and what: Why give at all? What impact do we want to have? What type of philanthropic family do we want to become?
Skip that step, and the foundation, or the donor-advised fund, or whatever vehicle comes next, becomes an expensive answer to a question nobody asked.
The Wrong Question, Asked in the Wrong Order
In my book Delusional Altruism, I call this the single most common mistake I see in philanthropy: asking “how” before “what,” and “what” before “why.” A foundation, a donor-advised fund, a charitable LLC — these are all “how” questions. They’re answers to a question nobody has asked yet, which is what the family actually wants their giving to accomplish, and why.
It’s an easy trap to fall into, because “how” feels like progress. You can Google it. You can call an attorney and have papers drafted by Friday. “Why do we give, and what do we actually want to change?” doesn’t resolve by Friday, so people skip it, and reach for the vehicle instead.
I get it. Structure feels like something you can control – a set of papers, a tax ID, a bank account. Purpose feels slippery by comparison. But a structure built before anyone answers “why” isn’t a decision. It’s a placeholder wearing decision’s clothes.
What Happens When the Order Gets Reversed
I’ve watched this play out with families managing eight figures and families managing seven. The vehicle gets set up, funded, and then… not much happens. A donor-advised fund becomes a parking lot for appreciated stock, funded every December for the deduction and granted out sporadically, without much conviction behind where it goes. A private foundation becomes an annual filing obligation nobody’s excited about, because nobody agreed on what it was for before the attorney set it up.
Contrast that with the Vadon Foundation in Seattle. It started the way most do: reactive giving to local causes as needs came up. Then its founder, tech entrepreneur Mark Vadon, and executive director Dave LaSarte-Meeks did the harder work first. They asked what they actually wanted their philanthropy to accomplish, and landed on something specific: sustaining thriving indigenous nations for generations to come. The foundation itself didn’t change. What changed was that a real answer to “why” finally showed up, and the existing structure suddenly had a job to do.
That’s the whole game. The vehicle rarely needs to change. The thinking behind it does.
Three Questions, in the Right Order
You don’t need a strategic planning process that eats up a year to find out where a family stands. You need three questions, asked in this order, not reshuffled.
Why do we give? Not the brochure answer. The real one. If family members answer this differently from each other, that’s not a crisis, it’s information: the structure conversation is premature, no matter how ready everyone feels to just get something set up.
What, specifically, do we want our giving to accomplish? A family that can only say “we want to help” hasn’t answered this yet. A family that can say “we want to reduce chronic absenteeism in our county’s public schools” has. Notice neither answer mentions a vehicle. It shouldn’t yet.
How should we structure it? This is the only one of the three that touches a foundation, a DAF, or anything else with a tax ID. It comes last on purpose. By the time you get here, the answer is usually obvious, because the job the money needs to do is already clear.
Ask them out of order and you get a structure shaped like a guess. Ask them in order and you get one shaped like a decision.
You Don’t Need a Year. You Need an Afternoon.
Here’s the part that surprises people: this doesn’t have to take long. I regularly run what I call a strategic sprint with clients, formulating real clarity on purpose and priorities in as little as seven hours, not seven months. The families who assume this requires an extended, expensive process are usually the ones avoiding the conversation, not the ones who’ve tried and found it slow.
If a client tells you they’ll get to the “why” conversation after the foundation is set up, that’s backward, and it’s worth saying so. The paperwork will always feel more urgent than the purpose. It’s just never actually more important.
The Advisors Who Ask “Why” First Become the Ones Clients Keep
More families are arriving at philanthropy for the first time than at almost any point I’ve seen, through a liquidity event, an inheritance, or a next generation stepping into decisions their parents used to make alone. Nearly all of them will open the conversation with the “how” question. Should we do a foundation? A DAF? Something else?
The honest answer is: not yet. Structure is the easiest part of philanthropy to get right, and the hardest part to unwind once it’s been built around the wrong purpose. The families who get the order right aren’t smarter or wealthier than the ones who don’t. They just answered “why” and “what” before anyone reached for the forms.
Your clients don’t need you to explain their vehicle options faster. They need you to ask what the money is for, first.







